h1

Finally, Someone Makes A Game About Shooting White People

April 9, 2008

So I woke up and checked my daily subscriptions, one of which linked me to an article in the New York Times about an online ‘test’ hosted by the University of Chicago Psychology department. Here’s a quote from the NYT piece:

To my horror, I turn out to be a racist.

The University of Chicago offers an on-line psychological test in which you encounter a series of 100 black or white men, holding either guns or cellphones. You’re supposed to shoot the gunmen and holster your gun for the others.

I shot armed blacks in an average of 0.679 seconds, while I waited slightly longer — .694 seconds — to shoot armed whites. Conversely, I holstered my gun more quickly when encountering unarmed whites than unarmed blacks.

Being the cunning, ruthless blogger that I am, I decided that there couldn’t be a better way to follow the outrageous success of the Top 13 Hottest Men of Gaming, In Color series than to upstage someone who writes for the Times. So I opened up the test and proceeded to let loose. 60 dead honkeys and negative 740 points later, I realize that the negative 20 points every time I shot an unarmed white man wasn’t a bug – the game wanted me to shoot armed people, not white people. Oops.

So I tried it again and scored a whopping 600 points – I think I accidentally shot 3 unarmed white guys and 1 unarmed black guy. (Sorry to the last guy there. My bad.) Interestingly enough, my reaction times didn’t parallel the NYT writers’; it took me 599ms to react to the armed black guys compared to 609ms to react to the armed white guys, and 672ms to react to the unarmed black guys compared to 682ms to react to the unarmed white guys. So the difference by race was ~10ms, but I seemed to be most suspicious of the unarmed white guys. (“You sure you don’t have a gun? That looks like a knife. Or smallpox – you never know with these guys.”) One would think that, having grown up in a white-dominant world, I’d be quicker to shoot black men and slowest to not-shoot them, but I guess that’s not the case.

As the game attempts to interrogate the internalized prejudices underlying the Amadou Diallo shooting, it’s designed to ‘reward’ shooting over not shooting; the biggest point score is +10 for correctly shooting, as opposed to +5 for correctly not shooting, and the penalty for incorrectly shooting is -20, compared to -40 for incorrectly not shooting. It’s also configured so that the right hand is used to shoot and the left is used to holster, which is significant insofar as most of the population is right-handed, and I’d imagine that would affect our reaction times. I wonder how the results would change if we flipped the controls – which half of our brain is the one that recognizes the shape of a gun?

Still, that ~10ms is pretty significant. I’m going to try switching to a white-skinned player model in Urban Terror and see if these results hold out.

pat m.

EDIT: I just did a trial run through the game where I held the “/” key down. It reported:

Black Armed: 46.64ms

Black Unarmed: 52.16ms

White Armed: 46.08ms

White Unarmed: 52.28ms

Not really sure why this discrepancy exists between armed/unarmed and black/white if I’m just holding the button down. Huh.

Advertisements

9 comments

  1. Here’s my score:

    Your Score: 415
    Average reaction time:
    Black Armed:683.08ms
    Black Unarmed:796.92ms
    White Armed:734.64ms
    White Unarmed:808.68ms

    I suck at figuring out who to shoot and who not to shoot. 🙂


  2. Eh I was kinda twitchy

    Your Score: 480
    Average reaction time:
    Black Armed:653.64ms
    Black Unarmed:707.96ms
    White Armed:741.2ms
    White Unarmed:730.56ms


  3. I held the “/” key down during the entire test and received the following data:

    Your Score: -500
    Average reaction time:
    Black Armed:32.72ms
    Black Unarmed:32.68ms
    White Armed:32.76ms
    White Unarmed:32.72ms

    I can’t really explain why this occurred.


  4. i shoot white people

    Game Over
    Your Score: -35
    Average reaction time:
    Black Armed:724.32ms
    Black Unarmed:725.92ms
    White Armed:686.08ms
    White Unarmed:777.8ms


  5. […] As my previous post indicated, shooting white people is a surprisingly popular activity. That’s why most people didn’t complain about the […]


  6. My score is:
    Your Score: 635
    Average reaction time:
    Black Armed:620.28ms
    Black Unarmed:736.2ms
    White Armed:636.48ms
    White Unarmed:698.68ms
    I was shot twice, once each by a white and black shooter for twitching the hoster key instead of the zap button, however…

    I tried to do the test semi-seriously, and two things stood out that may have made this test kind of one sided. I shot quickly when a gun shape was clear and distinct, and I hesitated when the target was in a combat stance with a hard to see object in his hands. That said with the above conditions you can shift results to mean anything you want with “unintentional” props assignments.


  7. I did it, closed the window before i copied my score, but I was faster shooting black guys and gave white guys longer before I decided not to shoot them.

    I really like the idea behind this, but this test is not really that accurate. There were more black men in an aggressive stance holding something other than a gun than there were white guys holding hard to spot guns.

    The idea behind this test is really cool, too bad you can’t trust anyone to be unbiased in the way they design a test.


  8. fuck all ya’ll cause i’ll kill all you crackers!!!!! and thats not a game either.


  9. It’s really a cool and useful piece of info.
    I am satisfied that you shared this useful info with
    us. Please stay us informed like this. Thanbk you ffor sharing.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: